What If You Caught The Ball- Syracuse Edition

This past Saturday, the New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter got his 3,000th hit of his Major League Baseball career.  He also became the first Yankee in the organization’s history to reach that milestone (not Ruth or Mantle, Jeter did it first).  As many of you probably know by now, that hit was a home run.

The ball was caught by 23 year old Yankees fan Christian Lopez.  In a move that has many stunned and others praising his actions, he returned the ball to Jeter in exchange for some autographed items and Yankee tickets for the rest of the season (in a suite and includes any post season games held at Yankee Stadium).  Many have speculated that the ball had a value of up to $250,000 and the value of what he got was approximately $70,000 (or at list this is the numbers Bloomberg quotes in this article).

I have heard various comments about what someone would do but truly, until you are in their shoes, how could you know for sure?  Many have even speculated that the Yankees shortchanged the fan and owe him more since they are making millions off the hit already.

So here is my question for those who are not Yankees fans, what would you do if this was a Syracuse situation? I can’t think of a scenario where the value would equal this exactly and a fan would have access to the ball but let’s take one hypothetical situation where I know a ball would be valuable to a Syracuse fan somewhere.

Enter Hakim Warrick and the magic that is 2003 National Championship championship.

In case you are not familiar with the situation, this block above is one of the greatest plays in Syracuse University sports history.  In 1987, Keith “frickin” Smart hit a last second shot to beat Syracuse for the championship and created a dark day in our history.  That moment was somewhat redeemed when Hak blocked a shot with .7 seconds that could have tied the game and thus broken the hearts of many Syracuse fans.  Instead Syracuse won 81-78 and Coach Boeheim finally got the title he rightfully deserved in 1987.

So take a look at the shot and imagine you are down there on the floor in New Orleans and you catch that ball.  You are a huge Syracuse fan and you now have the ball in your hands that potentially guaranteed our place in history as national champions.  Do you tell them to contact your lawyers because this ball is a part of history and it is in your possession now? Or do you give it back and simply ask to shake Hak’s hand for the awesome block?

I would like to think I would hand the ball back but there is a part of me that would seriously want to hang onto it in the hopes of getting the players to sign it later one day making it more valuable.  I also think if Hak or Coach Boeheim came up to me and asked for it back, I would have a hard time saying no to them.  So I ask you, what would you do with the ball that was blocked onto your lap and was part of a moment that 8 years later is still spoken about with admiration and earned Hak a spot in Syracuse hearts forever?

About Orange Chuck

You can find me at @orangechuck on Twitter and I can answer any questions you may have. Other than that, I try to be a positive person and live a positive life. :)
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to What If You Caught The Ball- Syracuse Edition

  1. If I didn’t give it back, I would give it to a young person that was a Big fan of the Orange Men.

    • orangechuck says:

      Hello Mrs. Relyea. Glad to hear from you. I have a feeling you would find someone who would enjoy the ball and if not, just let me know and I would take it ha.
      I actually have done the same thing when I catch a foul ball at a baseball game.I will see if a little kid is around who wants it and give it to them. I love watching a game but seeing them that excited is so genuine and worth it.
      Thank you for taking the time to reply.

  2. Steve Bartman says:

    It’s a basketball, not a baseball or a hockey puck. I’d think that the referee would ask for the basketball back so the game could continue.

    • orangechuck says:

      True. Scenario is not perfect but they have other basketballs and who is to you can’t take it if you caught it? I know the would try to get it but wont hold the game all day to get it back.
      Thanks for the response.

    • JoeFieldsEra says:

      Imagine the block happened as time expired. They wouldn’t need the ball back and it would probably get lost in the postgame mayhem.

      • orangechuck says:

        Excellent addition to the scenario. I mean Hak will probably want it too and then what do you do? Do you just give it to him and thank him for the effort or tell him to have the AD contact your lawyer and you can work it out later for a price? I honestly have no idea what I would do in the excitement.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s